Opinion

Opinion: The Total-Price Rule Should Not Stop at Tickets and Hotels

The FTC's fee rule works as designed, and a $10 million StubHub settlement shows it. The case for extending the same up-front pricing principle to more of the economy is stronger than the case against.

Calculator, glasses, and pens on a white desk

A federal rule that requires the full price to be shown up front has now been tested in an enforcement case, and it passed. That is a good reason to ask why the protection covers only two corners of the economy.

What the rule actually requires

The Federal Trade Commission’s Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees took effect on May 12, 2025. According to the FTC’s own guidance, it applies to live-event tickets (concerts, sports, theater) and short-term lodging (hotels, motels, vacation rentals and platform home shares). It reaches any business that offers, displays or advertises them, including resellers, third-party platforms and travel agents.

In plain terms, a seller must show the total price, including mandatory fees it knows about, more prominently than any other pricing information. Only government charges, shipping and optional add-ons may be left out of that headline figure, and they must be disclosed before payment is requested. The final amount due must appear before the buyer pays.

Requirement What it means for a shopper
Total price up front The first number is the number you pay
Prominence Total price outshines other pricing text
Fee descriptions Vague labels such as “service fees” are discouraged
Final amount before payment No new surprises at the last click

Did the rule work, or is it only on paper?

The first big test came in April 2026. According to an FTC announcement dated April 9, 2026, StubHub agreed to pay $10 million to fund refunds. The agency alleged the company advertised ticket prices after the rule took effect without showing the full amount buyers would pay, including mandatory fees, and that the violations appeared in its first three pricing displays, including for high-demand NFL tickets ahead of the league’s schedule release on May 14, 2025. Refunds go to consumers who bought tickets for U.S. live events between May 12 and 14, 2025, with the money due within 90 days of the order. The Commission voted 2-0 to authorize the complaint and proposed order.

Three days of sales produced a $10 million bill. That is a signal to every seller in covered markets that the rule is being read as written.

Why is the rule so narrow?

The rule does not cap fees, and it does not ban any category of fee. The FTC says plainly that it does not address industries beyond tickets and lodging, and that dynamic pricing remains permitted so long as the pricing is not misleading. Those are sensible design choices for a rule meant to survive scrutiny. They also leave a lot untouched.

Anyone who has watched a price grow between a search page and a checkout screen knows the pattern is not unique to concerts. Delivery fees, “convenience” charges, mandatory add-ons and processing surcharges turn up in many industries. A shopper comparing two options cannot compare them if only one lists the real figure. The same logic that justified the ticket rule, that a price which is not the price distorts competition, applies well beyond arenas.

The strongest argument against widening it

The best counter-argument deserves a fair hearing. Disclosure rules impose costs, and the more industries they reach, the harder they are to write well. Prices in some sectors depend on variables a seller cannot know in advance: distance, usage, tax jurisdiction, a customer’s circumstances. A rule demanding one total price could force sellers to display misleading averages or to withdraw online quotes altogether. And mandatory totals do nothing to stop a seller from raising the base price, so consumers may gain clarity without gaining savings.

Those points are real, and they explain why the existing rule is carefully limited to knowable, mandatory charges and carves out government fees and optional extras. But they argue for careful drafting, not for permanent exemption. Sectors where the mandatory charges are fixed and known when a price is shown have no good excuse for hiding them.

What clarity buys that caps never could

Clarity is a modest goal. It does not promise lower prices. It promises comparability, and comparability is what lets competition do its work. When fees are visible, a seller with lower fees can advertise the fact honestly. When they are hidden, the honest seller is penalized for showing a higher number first.

The same principle shows up elsewhere in household finance. Readers who have read our explainer on what sending money home really costs know how much of a transfer’s price can sit in an exchange-rate margin rather than a stated fee. Opaque pricing is not a ticketing quirk. It is a recurring design choice.

Where enforcement still has to catch up

A rule is only as good as its follow-through. Fee disclosure also sits alongside a wider consumer-protection landscape in which shoppers are already asked to be wary of imposter scams built around fake alerts and, as our explainer on what the Do Not Call Registry does and does not stop shows, tools that promise more than they deliver. Regulators have limited staff and a long list of priorities. A single large settlement helps, but deterrence depends on enforcement being visible and repeated.

It also depends on the rule’s own limits. The FTC’s guidance says the rule’s penalties can include compliance orders, refunds and civil penalties, but it does not state a per-violation amount in that guidance. A seller weighing the risk of a fee-hiding display needs to see numbers that outweigh the gain.

A modest proposal: extend it where the facts are knowable

The principle should travel wherever mandatory charges are known at the moment a price is shown. That would mean looking first at sectors where hidden mandatory fees draw the most consumer complaints and where totals can be calculated in advance. Rulemaking would need evidence, public comment and tailored carve-outs, just as the original did. Congress could also act, though the FTC’s rulemaking route has already proved workable.

The case for finishing the job

The ticket and hotel rule is not a regulatory overreach. It is a narrow, tested requirement that sellers tell buyers what they will pay. Its early enforcement record suggests it works, and its stated limits answer most of the obvious objections. The sensible next step is to ask which other markets deserve the same simple promise: the first price you see is the price you pay, apart from taxes and truly optional extras.

This article is general information and opinion, not legal or financial advice.

Sources: Federal Trade Commission

Latest stories